Looking for a supreme pizza in Buffalo? Reza’s Pizza on Kenmore Ave already makes one. It’s called the Mix Pizza, and it stacks chicken, pepperoni, and veggies on one pie. If you grew up ordering a combination pizza or an everything pizza, this is basically that pie, just under Reza’s own name. Locals around Kenmore already order it by the box.
What’s on Reza’s Mix Pizza
The Mix Pizza keeps things simple and full at the same time. It layers chicken, pepperoni, and a mix of veggies (bell peppers, mushrooms, olives, and onions) over melted mozzarella. Everything sits on hand-stretched dough with a scratch-made sauce underneath. Reza’s bakes each pie to order, so you get a hot pizza instead of one that’s been sitting around. Want to see the full lineup first? Check out the Mix Pizza on our menu before you order.
Why a loaded pizza is great value
A loaded pizza like this one saves you from having to pick just one thing. You get protein from the chicken and pepperoni, plus real vegetables, all on a single crust. That means fewer sides to order and less back-and-forth when everyone in your group wants something different.
Think about a typical group order. One person wants meat, another wants veggies, and somebody always asks for “a little of everything.” Normally that turns into two or three pizzas, plus some awkward math on who owes what. The Mix Pizza skips all of that. One pie covers several cravings at once, and it’s an easy way to try Reza’s without choosing between three separate pizzas. It also works well for game nights or office lunches, where you want variety but don’t want to juggle five boxes.
How Reza’s makes it fresh
Reza’s doesn’t skip the basics. The dough gets hand-stretched each day, and the sauce is made from scratch instead of poured from a can. From there, the pizza goes straight into the oven and comes out baked to order, not reheated from a warming tray. That matters more than it sounds. A pizza that sits under a heat lamp loses its crust, and the toppings start to dry out. Baking to order keeps the cheese pulling and the veggies with a bit of bite left in them. Curious about the process? See how we make our dough and the rest of the kitchen routine.
Sizes and prices
Pricing at Reza’s stays simple. Here’s the Mix Pizza by size.
| Size | Price |
| Small | $8 |
| Medium | $14 |
| Large | $18 |
Feeding a group? The large gives you the most coverage for the price. Ordering for one or two? The small still comes loaded with all three toppings, so you’re not paying more just to get the full mix.
Order a supreme pizza in Buffalo.
Ready to try it? Order the Mix Pizza online or call Reza’s directly at (716) 262-0803. Reza’s is open daily from 11 AM to 9 PM at 1803 Kenmore Ave. Pair it with wings or fries from the menu, or grab a second pie if you’re feeding a crowd.
If you’re not sure what else to add, wings are a safe bet since they share that same chicken and pepperoni flavor profile. Got a question first? You can always find us on Kenmore Ave or give the shop a call. And if you liked this one, our recent post on Buffalo wing styles is worth a read too.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a supreme pizza?
A supreme pizza usually means a loaded pie with a mix of meats and vegetables on one crust. At Reza’s, that pie is the Mix Pizza.
What’s on Reza’s Mix Pizza (their supreme-style pie)?
It comes topped with chicken, pepperoni, bell peppers, mushrooms, olives, and onions, all on mozzarella over hand-stretched dough.
What sizes and prices does it come in?
The Mix Pizza comes in small for $8, medium for $14, and large for $18. All three sizes get the same full topping mix.
Can I order it for pickup or delivery in Buffalo?
Yes. Order online or call (716) 262-0803 for pickup or delivery. Reza’s is open 11 AM to 9 PM daily.